A 6-MONTH HOME-USAGE TRIAL OF 0.1-PERCENT AND 0.2-PERCENT DELMOPINOL MOUTHWASHES .1. EFFECTS ON PLAQUE, GINGIVITIS, SUPRAGINGIVAL CALCULUS AND TOOTH STAINING
N. Claydon et al., A 6-MONTH HOME-USAGE TRIAL OF 0.1-PERCENT AND 0.2-PERCENT DELMOPINOL MOUTHWASHES .1. EFFECTS ON PLAQUE, GINGIVITIS, SUPRAGINGIVAL CALCULUS AND TOOTH STAINING, Journal of clinical periodontology, 23(3), 1996, pp. 220-228
Delmopinol is a morpholinoethanol derivative which, in mouthrinses use
d in the absence of normal oral hygiene, has been shown effective in t
he inhibition of plaque and gingivitis. The aim of this study was to d
etermine the adjunctive oral hygiene benefits and safety of delmopinol
rinses when used alongside normal toothcleaning. This 6-month home us
e study was a placebo-controlled, double-blind, randomised parallel de
sign evaluating 0.1% and 0.2% delmopinol rinses and structured to conf
orm with the ADA Council of Dental Therapeutics guidelines. A total of
450 dentate male and female subjects were recruited who had no releva
nt medical or pharmacotherapy histories determined from a full medical
examination, including haematological and biochemical tests. Subjects
had moderate levels of plaque and gingivitis. At baseline, 3 and 6 mo
nths subjects were scored for plaque. gingivitis, tooth stain and supr
agingival calculus, with plaque sampled for microbiological analysis,
Additionally, oral mucosal examinations were performed and subjects qu
estioned for adverse symptoms. Baseline special tests were repeated at
the end of the study. After baseline examinations, the subjects recei
ved a professional prophylaxis, provided with the allocated mouthwash
and instructed to use 10-ml volumes for 60 s 2xdaily and where appropr
iate after toothbrushing and meals, Demographic features of the 3 grou
ps were similar and losses to trial were small. Adverse signs and symp
toms included transitory numbness of the tongue, tooth and tongue stai
ning, taste disturbance and rarely mucosal soreness and erosion. All l
ocal side-effects were less commonly reported at 6 compared to 3 month
s and only 6 subjects were withdrawn because of adverse event. No syst
emic effects attributable to the agent were observed and no significan
t shifts in haematological or biochemical parameters occurred. All gro
ups showed considerable improvements in oral hygiene and gingival heal
th with some significant differences in favour of 0.2% delmopinol comp
ared to placebo for gingivitis and more particularly plaque. Staining
was also significantly increased in the delmopinol groups but not calc
ulus. In the present study, a considerable Hawthorne effect occurred,
which must in part explain why only a modestly significant effect was
achieved. (C) Munksgaard, 1996.