It has been shown that performance improves during sleep more rapidly
after sleep deprivation than during normal sleep. Recovery after sleep
deprivation is also characterized by a different sleep stage distribu
tion and by a decreased metabolic rate compared to a normal night of s
leep. The present study examined whether sleep during a period of incr
eased metabolic rate was less restorative than a normal period of slee
p. Twelve normal young adults participated for two 4-day periods. In e
ach period, an undisturbed baseline sleep night was followed by baseli
ne testing. On the subsequent night, Ss slept a total of 212 min, star
ling at 0200 h after consuming placebo or 400 mg of caffeine. After th
e nap, subjects remained awake for 41 h until beginning an undisturbed
night of recovery sleep. During the period of sleep loss, subjects re
mained at the sleep laboratory where they performed computer tests and
MSLTs, The caffeine produced a significant increase in metabolic rate
during the nap. Although total sleep time was held constant, there wa
s an increase in stage 1 and a decrease in stage 4 sleep after caffein
e use. Performance on addition and vigilance tasks was significantly d
ecreased after the caffeine plus nap condition. However, no significan
t differences were found on the MSLT, and subjective vigor was signifi
cantly greater following the caffeine and nap combination. It was conc
luded that the beneficial effect of sleep in maintaining performance w
as decreased by increased physiological activation during sleep.