We compared the effectiveness of personalized asthma self-management r
ecommendations with that of a group self-management program. We assign
ed each of 34 asthma patients randomly to one of three conditions: ind
ividualized asthma self-management, group asthma self-management, and
control. We derived individualized self-management recommendations fro
m patient recordings of asthma occurrence, asthma precipitants, and pe
ak expiratory flow rate made during a 3-month period. The group progra
m we used was the Wheezers Anonymous program. As compared to a control
group of patients who received no self-management training, the patie
nts in both the individualized and group condition evidenced improveme
nt of pulmonary function, as measured daily with a home peak flow mete
r. The improvement was equivalent for patients in the two conditions.
Patients in the individualized condition also exhibited a drop in freq
uency of asthma attacks, but patients in the group condition did not.
We concluded that individualized asthma self-management is effective i
n reducing symptoms of asthma.