Jl. Paquay et al., IMMEDIATE AND DAY-TO-DAY REPRODUCIBILITY OF THE SIGNAL-AVERAGED ELECTROCARDIOGRAM IN PATIENTS WITH CORONARY-ARTERY DISEASE, PACE, 19(4), 1996, pp. 443-454
The purpose of this study was to prospectively evaluate the immediate
(5 minutes) and short-term (1 day) reproducibility of the signal-avera
ged electrocardiogram (SAECG) in patients with coronary artery disease
. A total of 59 consecutive patients with coronary artery disease (50
male, 9 female, mean age 59 +/- 13 years) were included, Analysis was
performed using a commercially available system with high-pass filters
of 25, 40, and 80 Hz without any change in electrode position. The fo
llowing time-domain parameters were measured: (1) total filtered QRS d
uration; (2) duration of high-frequency low-amplitude signals (HFLA);
and (3) root-mean-square voltage of She terminal 40 ms of the QRS comp
lex (RMS40). Correlation between pairs of measurements was excellent,
ranging from 0.91-0.99 for QRS and HFLA duration, and from 0.83-0.98 f
or RMS40 value. However, the range of differences was wide for all par
ameters, especially at 25 and 80 Hz, revealing marked individual varia
tions in selected cases. The immediate reproducibility of an initially
normal SAECG was 95% at 25 Hz, 100% at 40 Hz, and 81% at 80 Iii; figu
res for an initially abnormal SAECG were 89%, 91%, and 93%, respective
ly, and the coefficient of agreement kappa was highest at 40 Hz than a
t 25 or 80 Hz. Discordant results were most frequently observed in pat
ients with borderline values, or in cases with nonsimilar residual noi
se levels. In conclusion the immediate and day-to-day reproducibility
of the SAECG is excellent in patients with chronic stable coronary art
ery disease. However, individual variations are observed in selected c
ases, leading to modification in interpretation of the result. For thi
s reason, individual reproducibility should be considered before evalu
ating the effect of any therapeutic intervention on the SAECG, especia
lly in patients with borderline values of the quantitative parameters
of the SAECG.