Estimation of vertical velocity is a key issue for understanding ocean
physics and transport of biogeochemical tracers. We examine the accur
acy of estimating vertical velocity in fronts with the omega equation.
The diagnostic performance of the omega equation is evaluated by usin
g vertical velocities obtained from simulation of frontal instabilitie
s in a primitive equation model as a reference. We use two traditional
quasigeostrophic methods in which the how is either a geostrophic flo
w computed from density or a nondivergent flow derived from vorticity
and also test two new formulations: a quasigeostrophic method using th
e total flow held and the semigeostrophic omega equation. Results show
that all four formulations correctly diagnose the vertical velocity p
attern. However, estimates provided by the traditional quasigeostrophi
c formulations have systematic bias. In contrast, the two new techniqu
es, which are practically equivalent, produce unbiased vertical veloci
ty diagnostic at fronts. These results point out the importance of inc
luding higher order dynamics than quasigeostrophy to take into account
the ageostrophic advection in the front. Since adequate filtering of
ADCP data is not yet available to obtain a suitable total flow, the se
migeostrophic omega equation is proposed as the most valuable tool to
compute vertical velocities from high resolution density measurements.