NI AND ZN DOPING OF CU SITES IN SUPERCONDUCTING ND2-ZCEZCUO4, LA2-BETA-SR-BETA-CUO4, BI2SR2CACU2O8, BI1-CENTER-DOT-8PB0-CENTER-DOT-2SR2CA2CU3O10, YBA2CU3O7, ENTER-DOT-4BA1-CENTER-DOT-35LA0-CENTER-DOT-65CU3OX AND YBA2CU4O8
Ha. Blackstead et Jd. Dow, NI AND ZN DOPING OF CU SITES IN SUPERCONDUCTING ND2-ZCEZCUO4, LA2-BETA-SR-BETA-CUO4, BI2SR2CACU2O8, BI1-CENTER-DOT-8PB0-CENTER-DOT-2SR2CA2CU3O10, YBA2CU3O7, ENTER-DOT-4BA1-CENTER-DOT-35LA0-CENTER-DOT-65CU3OX AND YBA2CU4O8, Philosophical magazine. B. Physics of condensed matter. Statistical mechanics, electronic, optical and magnetic, 74(6), 1996, pp. 681-714
A unified Cooper pair-breaking picture is presented for the observed d
egradation of the superconducting critical temperatures by Cu-site Zn
and Ni impurities in Nd2-zCezCuO4, La2-betaSrbetaCuO4, Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8,
Bi1.8PbO.2Sr2Ca2- Cu3O10, La0.6Ca0.4Ba1.35La0.65Cu3Ox, (with x approxi
mate to 7), YBa2Cu3O7 and YBa2Cu4O8. Independent of any specific model
, the data alone require physics outside rite cuprate planes, and henc
e no two-dimensional cuprate-plane model can consistently explain all
the Zn and Ni pair-breaking data. In Nd2-xCezCuO4, Ni and Zn behave as
in a BCS superconductor. Although the Ni- and Zn-doping data for YBa2
Cu3O7 have been cited as providing the so-called 'smoking gun' conclus
ive proof of the spin-fluctuation model, we conclude that the underlyi
ng assumptions of that data-analysis, that Ni and Zn occupy the same s
ites and that Ni is a weaker pair-breaker than Zn, are invalid: we arg
ue that the exchange scattering of Cooper-pairs in YBa2Cu3Ox, is inope
rative. Thus, except for Nd2-zCezCuO4 whose charge-reservoirs are adja
cent to its cuprate-planes and hence are uniquely within the range of
exchange scattering by cuprate-plane Cu-site Ni ions, the exchange sca
ttering caused by the difference between cuprate-plane Ni and Zn impur
ities is inoperative in these high-temperature superconductors - a fac
t difficult and perhaps impossible to reconcile with any cuprate-plane
model of superconductivity that also features a Meissner effect and C
ooper pairing. We interpret the inoperative exchange scattering as evi
dence that the primary superconducting condensate is outside the range
of the exchange interaction - and hence in the charge reservoirs, rat
her than in the cuprate-planes. The trends in observed pair-breaking c
ritical compositions u(c) define approximately exponential functions o
f the distance d between the impurity sites and the charge-reservoir d
opant-oxygen - also indicative of charge reservoir superconductivity.
The critical tempertures T-c increase (approximately linearly) with d
(again, consistent with charge-reservoir superconductivity), suggestin
g that higher critical temperatures can be achieved in materials with
increased separation between the cuprate planes and the charge reservo
irs. The cuprate planes appear to be mechanically favourable, but elec
tronically unfavourable to superconductivity. A consistent explanation
of all the Ni- and Zn-doping data is obtained (i) if the superconduct
ivity originates in the charge-resevoir or dopant-oxygen regions of ea
ch unit cell (not in the cuprate planes), (ii) if the short-ranged exc
hange scattering by magnetic Ni readily breaks Cooper-pairs whose hole
s are located on nearest-neighbour oxygen ions only, (iii) if a longer
-ranged interaction is responsible for the degradation of T-c by Zn an
d by Ni distant from the superconducting condensate, and (iv) if polar
ization fluctuations are responsible for the Cooper pairing. Thr pair-
breaking data contradict nor only the spin-fluctuation d-wave pairing
model, but also all models with the superconductivity originating in c
uprate planes.