Ir. Bell et al., NEUROPSYCHIATRIC AND SOMATIC CHARACTERISTICS OF YOUNG-ADULTS WITH ANDWITHOUT SELF-REPORTED CHEMICAL ODOR INTOLERANCE AND CHEMICAL-SENSITIVITY, Archives of environmental health, 51(1), 1996, pp. 9-21
The psychological, neuropsychiatric, and somatic characteristics of yo
ung adults who have different degrees of cacosmia (i.e., feeling ''ill
'' from the odor of xenobiotic chemicals) and who have self-described
''chemical sensitivity'' were examined. A total of 800 college student
s completed the following: a self-rating scale for frequency of odor i
ntolerance for 10 common substances, Simon Environmental Illness Sympt
om Survey, the SCL90-9, Barsky Amplification Scale, Pearlin-Schooler M
astery Scale, Cheek-Buss and Kagan Shyness scales, Marlowe-Crowne Soci
al Desirability Scale, and a health-symptom and physician-diagnosed ch
ecklist. Two pairs of groups were compared: (1) subjects in the top 16
% (i.e., cacosmics) and bottom 15% (noncacosmics) of the sample with r
espect to odor intolerance scale scores; and (2) subjects from the ent
ire sample who did (28%) or did not (72%) consider themselves to be ''
especially sensitive to certain chemicals.'' Cacosmics and the chemica
lly sensitive subjects scored significantly higher on measures of psyc
hological distress and amplification of somatic symptoms, but there wa
s little evidence of lifestyle change, as assessed by the Simon Survey
. Compared with their respective comparison groups, cacosmic and chemi
cally sensitive groups had significantly higher incidences of illnesse
s associated with chemicals, alcohol intake, opiate drug use, and caff
eine use, even after controlling for the psychological measures and hi
stories of atopic allergy. Subjects with and without neuropsychiatric
symptoms were differentiated with respect to chemical odor intolerance
, but subjects with and without atopic allergies and possible autoimmu
ne diseases were differentiated with respect to chemical sensitivity.
Females were more cacosmic than males. Cacosmia is defined by a popula
tion subset, with or without occupational xenobiotic exposures or disa
bility, that has distress and symptom amplification and neuropsychiatr
ic and somatic symptoms, none of which are explained fully by psycholo
gical measures. Prospective clinical studies are possible with such in
dividuals. The data are also consistent with a time-dependent sensitiz
ation model for illness from low-level chemical exposures.