It is commonly assumed that passerine birds with open nests reduce the
risk of predation by concealing their nests. At a forest study site i
n northwestern Pennsylvania, about 50% of the Hooded Warbler (Wilsonia
citrina) nests were depredated-the primary cause of reproductive fail
ure. To test the hypothesis that concealed nests are less likely to be
depredated than conspicuous nests, we examined seven characteristics
of the warbler's nest and nest microhabitat in relation to nest predat
ion: nest visibility, vegetation density surrounding the nest, height
of nest, height of nest substrate, nest-substrate species, height of c
ryptic dead-leaf base of nest, and proximity of nest to a microedge. S
uccessful and depredated nests (n = 97) did not differ in any of these
variables. In addition, we performed a vegetation-removal experiment
in which manipulated nests (n = 15) with surrounding vegetation remove
d were on average 86% more visible overall than control nests (n = 15)
. The highly visible manipulated nests did not suffer higher predation
than control nests. Contrary to our hypothesis, our results show that
nest concealment is not an important factor in predator avoidance for
Hooded Warblers. This outcome would be expected if nest predation is
the result of nonspecialist predation that occurs by chance and is bas
ed on the location of available food in general.