J. Piepmeier et al., VARIATIONS IN THE NATURAL-HISTORY AND SURVIVAL OF PATIENTS WITH SUPRATENTORIAL LOW-GRADE ASTROCYTOMAS, Neurosurgery, 38(5), 1996, pp. 872-878
DATA FROM 55 consecutive patients with low-grade astrocytomas treated
between 1982 and 1990 were analyzed to determine specific outcome fact
ors, including time to recurrence, incidence of anaplastic transformat
ion, and survival. Gender, type of symptoms, contrast enhancement, and
timing of radiation therapy were not significant in determining outco
me. Patients who had symptoms for >2 years and underwent gross-total r
esection of the tumor, with age as a continuous variable, were associa
ted with significantly longer time to recurrence and survival. Within
the population of patients with low-grade astrocytomas, patients with
chronic epilepsy clearly had the best prognoses. There were no tumor r
ecurrences or deaths in 27 patients with chronic epilepsy, regardless
of the extent of surgery and without the use of radiotherapy. Ten-year
survival was 100% for 31 patients who underwent gross-total tumor res
ection, regardless of the length of preoperative symptoms. Immediate p
ostoperative radiotherapy did not prolong the time to recurrence, redu
ce the incidence of transition to more malignant tumors at recurrence,
or increase the length of survival when compared with delayed radioth
erapy. Because recurrence with a high-grade lesion caused 92% of the m
ortality in our series, the benefit in patients who underwent aggressi
ve surgery seems to result from a significant decrease in the risk of
recurrence when compared with patients who underwent anything less tha
n gross-total resection. Our data also suggest that variability in the
natural history of low-grade astrocytomas has a strong influence in d
etermining survival and that tumors associated with chronic epilepsy a
re much less likely to become more malignant over time.