Rt. Treinen et al., AN IMPROVED TECHNIQUE TO DETERMINE THE CONTROLLING UNSTABLE EQUILIBRIUM-POINT IN A POWER-SYSTEM, IEEE transactions on circuits and systems. 1, Fundamental theory andapplications, 43(4), 1996, pp. 313-323
The accuracy of stability assessment provided by the transient energy
function (TEF) method depends on the determination of the controlling
unstable equilibrium point (UEP), The technique that currently determi
nes the controlling UEP in the TEF method is based on the so-called ex
it point method and has also been recently labeled the BCU method, The
exit point method consists of two basic steps, First, the exit point
is approximated by the point theta(egsa), where the first maximum of t
he potential energy along the fault-on trajectory is encountered, Seco
nd, the minimum gradient point theta(mgp) along the trajectory from th
eta(egsa) is computed, The controlling UEP is then obtained by solving
a system of nonlinear algebraic equations with theta(mgp) as an initi
al guess, It has been observed that this method lacks robustness in th
e sense that the following two problems may occur, 1) There may be no
detection of the minimum gradient point theta(mgp) and hence, no deter
mination of the controlling UEP, 2) if theta(mgp) is found, then based
on the definition of the controlling UEP, it may not be in the domain
of convergence of the controlling UEP for the particular solving algo
rithm used, Hence, another equilibrium point, possibly a stable equili
brium paint, not the controlling UEP will be located, This results in
a flawed transient stability assessment, The result of this research h
as been the development of a new numerical technique for determining t
he controlling UEP, With an initial starting point that is close to th
e exit point this technique efficiently produces a sequence of points,
An analytical foundation for this method is given which shows that un
der certain assumptions this sequence will converge to the controlling
UEP, Hence this new technique exhibits a substantial improvement over
the exit point method because of the following reasons: (1) the techn
ique does not attempt to detect the point theta(mgp), (2) the techniqu
e can produce a point that is close to the controlling UEP thus avoidi
ng a domain of convergence problem, The analytical foundation is provi
ded for the unloaded gradient system, but an application of the techni
que to the IEEE 50-generator system shows that satisfactory stability
assessment is also obtained for more general systems, for which the ex
it point method fails.