A. Wilson et L. Weinstein, THE TRANSFERENCE AND THE ZONE OF PROXIMAL DEVELOPMENT, Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association, 44(1), 1996, pp. 167-200
The Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) is discussed, a construct that,
when introduced into psychoanalysis, advances understanding of the ke
y clinical relationship between the intrapsychic and the interpersonal
. Strands from several psychoanalytic formulations are brought togethe
r and forged into a coherent construct, which is then contrasted with
the transference. It is shown how the ZPD provides the transference wi
th its mutative potential. Just as the transference provides the motiv
ation for the recruitment of objects to accomplish its purposes (repet
ition), the ZPD leads to the recruitment of objects in order to accomp
lish its purposes (to learn by ushering individuals into a speech and
internalization community). Under the sway of the transference objects
are sought so that early disregulating experiences can be repeated an
d an opportunity provided for a better resolution. The ZPD works in ta
ndem with the transference, capitalizing on the impetus provided, allo
wing for the possibility of internalization, a beneficial outcome to t
ransference repetition which otherwise would have no agent of conflict
resolution. In analysis, when the transference and the ZPD enjoin smo
othly, the potential outcome is ''insight'' in a broad sense. The proc
esses of the ZPD define the optimal interpersonal context of psychoana
lysis, one that allows the intrapsychic to be best reached by analytic
interventions. Given the inevitability of mutual influences between a
nalyst and analysand, the analyst strives simultaneously to be in the
ZPD yet outside the transference with the analysand, a crucial tension
that is a constant, precarious technical factor. This useful tension
casts light on such procedural guides as optimal frustration and absti
nence.