T. Wood et P. Sellers, ASSESSMENT OF A PROBLEM-CENTERED MATHEMATICS PROGRAM - 3RD GRADE, Journal for research in mathematics education, 27(3), 1996, pp. 337-353
Six classes received problem-centered mathematics instruction for 2 ye
ars in second and third grade. This instruction was generally reflecti
ve of a socioconstructivist theory of knowing and compatible with reco
mmendations for reform in mathematics education. A class-by-instructio
n factorial design was used to compare students in problem-centered cl
asses for 2 years with students in problem-centered classrooms for 1 y
ear, and with students in textbook classes for 2 years on a standardiz
ed achievement test. In addition, classes using problem-centered instr
uction for 2 years were compared with students in problem-centered cla
sses for 1 year on an instrument designed to assess students' conceptu
al development in arithmetic and an instrument developed to examine pe
rsonal goals and beliefs about reasons for success in mathematics. The
results of the analyses indicate that significant differences exist i
n arithmetic learning for students in problem-centered classes for 2 y
ears on the standardized achievement test and the arithmetic test The
results indicate that after 2 years of instruction in reform-based cla
sses, students score significantly higher on standardized measures of
computational proficiency as well as conceptual understanding. Additio
nally, these students hold stronger beliefs about the importance of fi
nding their own or different ways to solve problems.