Ep. Zorrilla et al., RELATION OF STRESSORS AND DEPRESSIVE SYMPTOMS TO CLINICAL PROGRESSIONOF VIRAL ILLNESS, The American journal of psychiatry, 153(5), 1996, pp. 626-635
Objective: The aim of this research was to determine whether and in wh
om stressors and depressive symptoms facilitate clinical recurrence of
herpes simplex virus (HSV) and progression of HIV. Method: Meta-analy
tic techniques were used to review the relations of stressors and depr
essive symptoms to clinical recurrence of HSV in 16 published studies
and to indicators of HIV progression in 19 published studies. The auth
ors calculated average effect sizes, performed fixed effect and random
effect inferential analyses, tested for heterogeneous findings, and i
dentified potential moderating variables. Results: Depressive symptoms
were associated with a slightly increased risk of HSV recurrence and
increased reports of HIV-related symptoms, whereas stressors were not.
However; depressive symptoms were not associated with objective indic
ators of accelerated HIV progression. Stressor studies, especially tho
se that ascertained population-specific life events, found numerical a
nd functional decrements in circulating natural killer cell population
s. The candidate moderators identified include, for HSV recurrence, ag
e, sex, and medication status, and for HIV-related symptoms, age, race
, disease stage, and co-infection with HSV. Conclusions: Depressive sy
mptoms, but not stressors, increase the risk of HSV recurrence general
ly. Depressive symptoms do not appear to accelerate HIV progression ub
iquitously, although they are associated with increased reporting of H
IV-related symptoms. Future studies that ascertain population-specific
stressors should determine whether reductions in cytotoxic lymphocyte
s influence HIV disease progression. Moreover, researchers should inve
stigate the role of the identified moderators and recognized psychoimm
une moderators in existing and novel study groups. These analyses coul
d confirm that certain individuals are especially susceptible to the e
ffects on disease progression of stressors, depressive symptoms, or bo
th.