Jp. Mackenbach et al., DIFFERENCES IN THE MISREPORTING OF CHRONIC CONDITIONS, BY LEVEL OF EDUCATION - THE EFFECT ON INEQUALITIES IN PREVALENCE RATES, American journal of public health, 86(5), 1996, pp. 706-711
Objectives. Many studies of socioeconomic inequalities in the prevalen
ce of chronic conditions rely on self-reports. For chronic nonspecific
lung disease, heart disease, and diabetes mellitus, we studied the ef
fects of misreporting on variations in prevalence rates by respondents
' level of education. Methods. In 1991, a health interview survey was
conducted in the southeastern Netherlands with 2867 respondents. Respo
ndents' answers were compared with validated diagnostic questionnaires
in the same survey and the diagnoses given by the respondents' genera
l practitioners. Results. Misreporting of chronic lung disease, heart
disease, and diabetes may be extensive. Depending on the condition and
the reference data used, the confirmation fractions ranged between .6
1 and .96 and the detection fractions between .13 and .93. Misreportin
g varied by level of education, and although various patterns were obs
erved, the dominant pattern was that of more underreporting among less
educated persons. The effects on prevalence rates were to underestima
te differences by level of education to a sometimes considerable degre
e. Conclusions. Misreporting of chronic conditions differs by responde
nts' level of education. Health interview survey data underestimate so
cioeconomic inequalities in the prevalence of chronic conditions.