A. Bellin et al., ON TRANSPORT IN POROUS FORMATIONS CHARACTERIZED BY HETEROGENEITY OF EVOLVING SCALES, Water resources research, 32(12), 1996, pp. 3485-3496
Solute transport in natural formations at the regional scale is influe
nced by several scales of heterogeneity which correspond to the presen
ce of several geological units called facies. As customarily assumed i
n stochastic theories, inside the facies the transport can be characte
rized by a single scale of heterogeneity. At the regional scale Severa
l geological units are present such that a hierarchy of relevant scale
s needs to be defined. A possible model for this spatial variability a
ssumes the log conductivity as a random space function of stationary i
ncrements characterized by a power law semivariogram. With this hypoth
esis the ergodic dispersion coefficient grows unbounded as time increa
ses, leading to the phenomenon called anomalous dispersion, An alterna
tive approach considers the plume in nonergodic conditions and assumes
the effective dispersion coefficient, which is defined through differ
entiation in time of the expected value of the spatial second-order pl
ume moment, as representative of macrodispersion. Large differences ha
ve been observed in the resulting plume spreading while approaching th
e problem using the above alternative definitions. In this paper we pr
ovide first-order analytical solutions for the longitudinal effective
dispersion coefficient, D-L, as well as for the expected value of the
longitudinal spatial plume moment, [S-11] that complement semianalytic
al expressions recently proposed in literature. Furthermore, we provid
e a semianalytical expression for the standard deviation of the longit
udinal second-order moment which is important in assessing the interva
l of confidence of the estimation provided by [S-11]. Suitable numeric
al simulations are performed to validate analytical and semianalytical
expressions as well as to assess the impact of the cutoff in the log
conductivity power spectrum imposed by choosing a finite domain dimens
ion, We conclude that according to recently published results, the dis
persion is anomalous when the Hurst coefficients, H, is larger than 0.
5 while it is Fickian for H < 0.5. This is in contrast with the ergodi
c analysis which concludes that the dispersion is anomalous irrespecti
ve of the Hurst coefficient, Hence the effective dispersion coefficien
t is more effective than the ergodic dispersion. coefficient to repres
ent the plume spreading. However, the standard deviation of the longit
udinal spatial second-order moment is of the same order of magnitude a
s the expected value leading to the conclusion that the estimations pr
ovided by D-L and [S-11] are affected by large uncertainties. Numerica
l results are in good agreement with the analytical solutions, and und
er some hypotheses they are not influenced by the cutoff. This is not
the case for the ergodic second-order longitudinal moment, which stron
gly depends on the imposed cutoff.