I compare paternity defense strategies in the variable mating systems
of alpine accentors Prunella collaris and dunnocks P. modularis. I sho
w that in dunnocks breeding territoriality functions exclusively for m
ate defense. Male investment in territoriality increases with the numb
er of females they are defending, and when females are removed males s
harply decrease their song output and eventually abandon their territo
ries. Further, I show that paternity defense strategies vary in relati
on to group composition. In single-male groups there is greater invest
ment in territorial defense and less investment in mate guarding durin
g the female fertile period than in multimale groups. I discuss the in
fluence of the contrasting habitats of dunnocks and alpine accentors o
n their paternity defense strategies.