Rw. Healy et al., NUMERICAL EVALUATION OF STATIC-CHAMBER MEASUREMENTS OF SOIL-ATMOSPHERE GAS-EXCHANGE - IDENTIFICATION OF PHYSICAL PROCESSES, Soil Science Society of America journal, 60(3), 1996, pp. 740-747
The exchange of gases between soil and atmosphere is an important proc
ess that affects atmospheric chemistry and therefore climate. The stat
ic-chamber method is the most commonly used technique for estimating t
he rate of that exchange. We examined the method under hypothetical fi
eld conditions where diffusion was the only mechanism for gas transpor
t and the atmosphere outside the chamber was maintained at a fixed con
centration. Analytical and numerical solutions to the soil gas diffusi
on equation in one and three dimensions demonstrated that gas flux den
sity to a static chamber deployed on the soil surface was less in magn
itude than the ambient exchange rate in the absence of the chamber. Th
is discrepancy, which increased with chamber deployment time and air-f
illed porosity of soil, is attributed to two physical factors: distort
ion of the soil gas concentration gradient (the magnitude was decrease
d in the vertical component and increased in the radial component) and
the slow transport rate of diffusion relative to mixing within the ch
amber. Instantaneous flux density to a chamber decreased continuously
with time; steepest decreases occurred so quickly following deployment
and in response to such slight changes in mean chamber headspace conc
entration that they would likely go undetected by most field procedure
s. Adverse influences of these factors were reduced by mixing the cham
ber headspace, minimizing deployment time, maximizing the height and r
adius of the chamber, and pushing the rim of the chamber into the soil
. Nonlinear models were superior to a linear regression model for esti
mating flux densities from mean headspace concentrations, suggesting t
hat linearity of headspace concentration with time was not necessarily
a good indicator of measurement accuracy.