W. Forner, DAVYDOV SOLITON DYNAMICS IN PROTEINS .1. INITIAL STATES AND EXACTLY SOLVABLE SPECIAL CASES, JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR MODELING, 2(5), 1996, pp. 70-102
For the Davydov Hamiltonian several special cases are known which can
be solved analytically. Starting from these cases we show that the ini
tial state for a simulation using Davydov's ID1> approximation has to
be constructed from a given set of initial lattice displacements and m
omenta in form of a coherent state with its amplitudes independent of
the lattices site, corresponding to Davydov's ID2> approximation. In t
he ID1> ansatz the coherent state amplitudes are site dependent. The s
ite dependences evolve from this initial state exclusively via the equ
ations of motion. Starting the ID1> simulation from an ansatz with sit
e dependent coherent state amplitudes leads to an evolution which is d
ifferent from the analytical solutions for the special cases. Further
we show that simple construction of such initial states from the expre
ssions for displacements and momenta as functions of the amplitudes le
ads to results which are inconsistent with the expressions for the lat
tice energy. The site-dependence of coherent state amplitudes can only
evolve through the exciton-phonon interactions and cannot be introduc
ed already in the initial state. Thus also in applications of the ID1>
ansatz to polyacetylene always ID2> type initial states have to be us
ed in contrast to our previous suggestion [W. Forner, J. Phys.: Conden
s. Matter 1994, 6, 9089-9851, on p. 9105]. Further we expand the known
exact solutions in Taylor serieses in time and compare expectation va
lues in different orders with the exact results. We find that for an a
pproximation up to third order in time (for the wave function) norm an
d total energy, as well as displacements and momenta are reasonably co
rrect for a time up to 0.12-0.14 ps, depending somewhat on the couplin
g strengh for the transportless case. For the oscillator system in the
decoupled case the norm is correct up to 0.6-0.8 ps, while the expect
ation values of the number operators for different sites are reasonabl
y correct up to roughly 0.6 ps, when calculated from the third order w
ave function. The most important result for the purpose to use such ex
pansions for controlling the validity of ansatz states is, however, th
at the accuracy of S(t) and H(t) (constant in time, exact values known
in all cases) is obviously a general indicator for the time region in
which a given expansion yields reliable values also for the other, ph
ysically more interesting expectation values.