We investigate the categorization of two or more proposed reaction mec
hanisms for each of the following oscillatory enzymatic reactions: (1)
the peroxidase-oxidase reaction; (2) glycolytic oscillations; (3) osc
illations of cyclic AMP in slime mold cells; (4) enzymatic pH oscillat
ions; (5) calcium spiking in cytosol. We use prior work in stoichiomet
ric network analysis and categorization of oscillatory reactions to id
entify in each proposed reaction mechanism essential and nonessential
species, the specific role of each essential species, the connectivity
of the essential species, including the identification of the reactio
ns leading to oscillatory instabilities, and the category. For each mo
del, we predict the results of several experiments including relative
amplitudes, quench amplitudes, phase shifts, and sign symbolic concent
ration shifts and compare them with those from available experiments.
These and several other experiments such as bifurcation analysis,phase
response curves, entrainment experiments, qualitative and quantitativ
e pulsed species response, delay experiments, and external periodic pe
rturbation provide stringent tests of proposed reaction mechanisms, an
d appropriate ones are suggested to discriminate among competing mecha
nisms for a given reaction. We find the necessity for introducing a ne
w subcategory in our categorization of oscillatory reactions. The deta
ils of the analysis for reactions 2-5 and of the methods determining t
he categories are given in the Supporting Information.