Gr. Brown et al., PERSONALITY-CHARACTERISTICS AND SEXUAL FUNCTIONING OF 188 CROSS-DRESSING MEN, The Journal of nervous and mental disease, 184(5), 1996, pp. 265-273
The literature on cross-dressing men has been primarily limited to sel
f-identified patients at psychiatric clinics who are in distress. To u
nderstand the personality trait characteristics and sexual functioning
of nonpatient cross-dressers, 188 non-treatment-seeking male cross-dr
essers completed the NEO Personality Inventory (NEO-PT) and the Deroga
tis Sexual Functioning Inventory (DSFI). Respondents were classified a
s transvestites (TV; N = 83), transgenderists (TG; N = 61), or transse
xuals (TS;N = 44) based on self-report and the nature of their cross-g
ender activities (e.g., use of female hormones, desire for sex reassig
nment, and amount of time spent in female role). These diagnostic grou
ps did not differ on the five broad personality domains of the NEO-PI,
but TS men scored higher than TV and TG men on the Aesthetics facet s
cale of Openness to Experience (O). In terms of the DSFI scales, TS me
n reported lower sexual drive than TV and TG men, and TS and TG men ex
hibited greater psychiatric symptoms and feminine gender role, and poo
rer body image than TV men. Upon exclusion of a group of 49 respondent
s who previously sought treatment for psychological problems, no signi
ficant differences emerged among the three diagnostic groups on the NE
O-PI domain and facet scales. Consideration of the DSFI scales showed
that TS men experienced less sexual drive, more psychiatric symptoms,
and a greater feminine gender role than TV or TG men. This study sugge
sts that cross-dressers not seen for clinical reasons are virtually in
distinguishable from non-cross-dressing men using a measure of persona
lity traits, a sexual functioning inventory, and measures of psycholog
ical distress. These results emphasize the importance of using clinica
l significance criteria as required by DSM-TV guidelines before diagno
sing men who cross-dress with an axis I disorder.