Objective: Past research has suggested that subtypes of anorexia nervo
sa (restricting vs. binge eating/purging) correspond to differing degr
ees of impulsivity and personality psychopathology. We further investi
gated potential differences between these diagnostic subtypes. Method:
We compared restricting anorexics (n = 100) to binge/purging anorexic
s (n = 71) with regard to symptom presentation and history, impulsivit
y, eating and related attitudes (Eating Disorders Inventory), and pers
onality psychopathology. Results: We found that the two diagnostic sub
types did not differ in age at intake, body mass index at intake, or a
ge at first diet. Binge/purging anorexics were more likely than restri
cters to have attempted suicide or engaged in stealing, but the two gr
oups did not differ in likelihood of having engaged in self-injury or
in reported drug problems. The two anorexia nervosa subtypes did not d
iffer in age at onset of menses, likelihood of having engaged in mastu
rbation or sexual intercourse, age of onset of sexual activity, or sat
isfaction with current levels of sexual activity. Likewise, the two gr
oups of anorexia nervosa patients did not differ with regard to scores
on the Eating Disorders Inventory or Millon personality measures. Dis
cussion: Results are discussed in relation to the results of past rese
arch as well as historical fluctuation in the diagnosis of anorexia ne
rvosa subtypes. We propose that subtyping may be less useful than cons
ideration of eating disorder symptoms along continua. (C) 1996 by John
Wiley & Sons, Inc.