A collection of Pleurotus pulmonarius from New Zealand (NZP) showed co
mpatibility with four putatively separate biological species of Pleuro
tus (P. eryngii, P. ostreatus, P. populinus, P. pulmonarius) and with
an undescribed member of the P. ostreatus complex (P. ''abieticola'').
Pairings of monokaryotic strains of P. pulmonarius with those of NZP
were universally sexually compatible and produced stable, profileratin
g dikaryons. NZP compatibility with P. eryngii and P. populinus was pa
rtial, with a mixture of incompatible pairings, matings producing ephe
meral dikaryons, and matings producing stable, proliferating dikaryons
. Monokaryon pairings of NZP and FI ostreatus were either incompatible
or produced ephemeral, unstable, non-proliferating dikaryons. In all
cases, nuclear donation/migration was unilaterally into NZP. The matin
g system of NZP was tetrapolar although some features of the self-cros
s were atypical of the genus. Mating promiscuity by NZP with previousl
y biologically defined taxa raises issues concerning the nature of sep
aration of North American taxa.