Most theories suppose that during unconstrained retrieval easy-to-retr
ieve items will be accessed before hard-to-retrieve items. Recent free
-recall studies have supported a different access order, the cognitive
triage pattern, in which hard-to-retrieve items are accessed first. T
he present experiments demonstrated that this pattern enhances total r
ecall. In Experiments 1-3, clustering type measures of goodness of tri
age (grouping output according to items' levels of retrievability) pre
dicted total recall in children and adults. In Experiments 4 and 5, go
odness-of-triage measures predicted total recall when they were derive
d from on-line information about retrievability (error-success histori
es), but not when they were derived from normative information about r
etrievability (frequency and meaningfulness ratings).