Original reports on temporal arteritis and polymyalgia rheumatica were
reviewed before and after the introduction of steroid therapy to prev
ent blindness in temporal arteritis. In some cases, the original data
were reworked. There is evidence that both diseases have become more b
enign. As a result, the perceived risk of blindness is presently overe
stimated, as is the perceived benefit of steroids in reducing this ris
k, and neither should be used as support for an essential difference b
etween temporal arteritis and polymyalgia rheumatica. Indeed, no quali
tative differences otherwise exist and both are best viewed as facets
of a common disease spectrum with variable risk of adverse outcome. So
me of the difficulties in dealing with diseases characterized by varia
ble risk within present dichotomous classifications are discussed. It
is Likely that in many patients benign disease is presently undiagnose
d. It is likely that certain classifications of temporal arteritis and
polymyalgia rheumatica now in use lead to an overtreatment of some pa
tients with relatively benign disease.