Thermogenic methane yields can be estimated indirectly from the averag
e elemental composition of coals of different rank or inferred from th
e results of coal pyrolysis experiments. Unfortunately, most published
studies have been insufficiently detailed to estimate gas contents in
lignite, subbituminous coal and high-volatile B bituminous coal. In a
ddition, we note that the theoretical coalbed methane generation curve
s of Juntgen and Karweil and other commonly quoted papers overestimate
methane yield because they do not consider hydrogen loss from coal in
the form of water. In order to place better constraints on the econom
ic potential of methane in low-rank coals, anhydrous, sealed-tube pyro
lysis experiments were carried out on a Paleocene lignite from North D
akota. Experiments were conducted at heating rates of 10 degrees C/h a
nd 10 degrees C/day between temperatures of 100 and 454 degrees C. Wit
h increasing final pyrolysis temperature, mean random huminite/vitrini
te reflectance values increased from 0.31 to 1.61%, atomic WC values o
f the extracted coal decreased from 0.88 to less than 0.56, and methan
e yields increased to a maximum of 46 mL/g initial lignite, or approxi
mately 1560 cf/ton (dry, asl;-free basis) (cf = cubic feet). Based on
these results, coalification to high-volatile A bituminous-rank or hig
her (R(o) greater than or equal to 0.8%, atomic H/C less than or equal
to 0.72, and NAI [log(n-C-16/n-C-30)] greater than or equal to 0.03)
appears required to achieve a modest in situ economic threshold of 300
cf/ton methane. Pyrolysis yields were used to model early methane gen
eration with a series of parallel, first-order reactions with activati
on energies between 41 and 54 kcal/mol and a single frequency factor o
f 9.88 x 10(11) s(-1). Extrapolation of these parameters and a modifie
d version of the EASY%Ro vitrinite reflectance model to geologic heati
ng rates suggests that T > 120 degrees C and R(o) greater than or equa
l to 0.9% are required to exceed the 300 cf/ton threshold. We conclude
that while methane concentrations greater than 300 cf/ton may be foun
d in high-volatile B bituminous and lower rank coals, in most cases th
ey must be attributed to migrated gas or to near-surface (less than or
equal to 3000 ft) microbial activity.