R. Zardoya et A. Meyer, EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIPS OF THE COELACANTH, LUNGFISHES, AND TETRAPODS BASED ON THE 28S RIBOSOMAL-RNA GENE, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United Statesof America, 93(11), 1996, pp. 5449-5454
The origin of land vertebrates was one of the major transitions in the
history of vertebrates. Yet, despite many studies that are based on e
ither morphology or molecules, the phylogenetic relationships among te
trapods and the other two living groups of lobe-finned fishes, the coe
lacanth and the lungfishes, are still unresolved and debated. Knowledg
e of the relationships among these lineages, which originated back in
the Devonian, has profound implications for the reconstruction of the
evolutionary scenario of the conquest of land. We collected the larges
t molecular data set on this issue so far, about 3,500 base pairs from
seven species of the large 28S nuclear ribosomal gene. All phylogenet
ic analyses (maximum parsimony, neighbor-joining, and maximum likeliho
od) point toward the hypothesis that lungfishes and coelacanths form a
monophyletic group and are equally closely related to land vertebrate
s. This evolutionary hypothesis complicates the identification of morp
hological or physiological preadaptations that might have permitted th
e common ancestor of tetrapods to colonize land. This is because the r
econstruction of its ancestral conditions would be hindered by the dif
ficulty to separate uniquely derived characters from shared derived ch
aracters in the coelacanth/lungfish and tetrapod lineages. This molecu
lar phylogeny aids in the reconstruction of morphological evolutionary
steps by providing a framework; however, only paleontological evidenc
e can determine the sequence of morphological acquisitions that allowe
d lobe-finned fishes to colonize land.