M. Arshadi et al., SOLVATED SILYLIUM CATIONS - STRUCTURE DETERMINATION BY NMR-SPECTROSCOPY AND THE NMR AB INITIO/IGLO METHOD/, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 118(21), 1996, pp. 5120-5131
Sixty R(3)SiX/solvent (S) and R(2)HSiX/S systems with R = methyl, ethy
l, butyl and S = methylene chloride, DMPU, DMSO, sulfolane, HMPA, acet
onitrile, pyridine, N-methylimidazole, and triethylamine were investig
ated with the help of NMR spectroscopy for different concentration rat
ios of R(3)SiX/S and R(2)HSiX/S as well as different temperatures. Wit
h the help of measured delta(29)Si and delta(13)C chemical shifts as w
ell as (1)J(Si-C) and (2)J(Si-P) coupling constants, typical NMR param
eters for R(3)SiX and R(2)HSiX, R(3)Si(S)(+), R(2)HSi(S)(+), and R(2)H
Si(S)(2)(+) were established and discussed to distinguish between poss
ible silylium cation-solvent complexes and equilibria between them. In
addition, the NMR/ab initio/IGLO method (based on the continuum solve
nt model PISA and IGLO-PISA chemical shift calculations) was used to d
etermine geometry, stability, and other properties of Me(3)Si(S)(n)(+)
and Me(2)HSi(S)(n)(+) complexes in different solutions. NMR measureme
nts and ab initio calculations clearly show that R(3)Si(S)(+) and R(2)
HSi(S)(+) complexes with tetracoordinated Si are formed with solvents
(S) more nucleophilic than methylene chloride while complexes with two
S molecules and a pentacoordinated Si atom can only be found for R(3-
n)H(n)Si(+) cations with n greater than or equal to 1. This is a resul
t of internal (hyperconjugative) stabilization of R(3)Si(+) by alkyl g
roups and external stabilization by S coordination, as well as of ster
ic factors involving R and S. Complex binding energies are in the rang
e of 40-60 kcal/mol, which is significantly different from complex bin
ding energies in the gas phase. In all cases investigated, (weakly) co
valent bonds between Si and S are formed that exclude any silylium cat
ion character for the solvated R(3)Si(+) and R(2)HSi(+) ions.