The spectroscopic and structural properties of the perchlorate and tri
flate salts of N-n-butyl-retinylidene imine, 2 and 3, have been examin
ed in solution and solid phases. In solution these salts were found to
exhibit very similar UV and NMR spectroscopic properties. However, in
the solid state marked differences in their absorption spectra (2, la
mbda(max) = 504 nm; 3, lambda(max) = 445 nm) and C-13 NMR spectra were
found. The structures. of the two salts were determined by X-ray crys
tallography. The cations in each of the salts were shown to have very
similar conformations, detailed structures, and packing in their cryst
al lattices. The differences in the spectroscopic properties of the sa
lts in the solid state could not be accounted for on the basis of any
structural differences in the cations themselves. In terms of cation-a
nion interactions, a strong hydrogen bonding interaction was found in
each case between the N-H proton and an oxygen atom of the counterion.
However, there were significant differences between the two salts in
terms of the N-H ... O internuclear distances (2, N-H ... O = 2.939(7)
Angstrom and in 3, 2.85(1) Angstrom). The results are strongly sugges
tive that the wavelength and positive charge delocalization in retinyl
idene iminium salts are controlled by variation of the distance betwee
n the anion and the proton bonded to the Schiff base nitrogen atom. Th
e work reported here represents the first examples of secondary retiny
lidene iminium salts containing an N-alkyl substituent to be successfu
lly analyzed by X-ray crystallography. The relationship of these obser
vations in the solid state to the spectroscopic properties of the natu
ral visual pigments is explored.