Jd. Balakrishnan et R. Ratcliff, TESTING MODELS OF DECISION-MAKING USING CONFIDENCE RATINGS IN CLASSIFICATION, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance, 22(3), 1996, pp. 615-633
Classification implies decision making (or response selection) of some
kind. Studying the decision process using a traditional signal detect
ion theory analysis is difficult for two reasons: (a) The model makes
a strong assumption about the encoding process (normal noise), and (b)
the two most popular decision models, optimal and distance-from-crite
rion models, can mimic each other's predictions about performance leve
l. In this article, the authors show that by analyzing certain distrib
utional properties of confidence ratings, a researcher can determine w
hether the decision process is optimal, without knowing the form of th
e encoding distributions. Empirical results are reported for three typ
es of experiments: recognition memory, perceptual discrimination, and
perceptual categorization. In each case, the data strongly favored the
distance-from-criterion model over the optimal model.