Berger's book Kakteen is a constant source of nomenclatural uncertaint
y due to new combinations in genera that are obviously not accepted by
the author. The arguments in favour of and against accepting Berger's
combinations as validly published are discussed, and it is concluded
that they are not. The key to the understanding of Berger's taxonomic
concept is found in the introductory chapters where the author clearly
expounded his intentions. Therefore A. W. Hill is to be cited as vali
dating author of the names concerned.