Jl. Houk et Lj. Lewandowski, CONSULTANT VERBAL CONTROL AND CONSULTEE PERCEPTIONS, Journal of educational and psychological consultation, 7(2), 1996, pp. 107-118
High verbal control is a way of exercising interpersonal power and may
be an important influence on consultation process and outcome. In thi
s study, two groups of public school teachers were shown videotapes de
picting either high or low levels of consultant verbal control. Depend
ent measures included a consultation-acceptance rating, a behavioroid
measure assessing consultee commitment to future consultation meetings
, and a thought-listing technique soliciting covert cognitive response
s occurring while the teachers viewed the consultation exchanges. Resu
lts indicated that the verbal control manipulation produced difference
s in teachers' perceptions of the consultant's level of verbal control
. After viewing the vignettes, 16% of the teachers expressed willingne
ss to commit to future consultation. However, there was no apparent de
trimental effect of high consultant verbal control: Of those teachers
willing to commit, differences between high and low control were not s
ignificant. Post hoc analysis of acceptance scale items indicated that
participants thought the consultee learned more about the problem dis
cussed during the consultation under the high consultant verbal contro
l condition. Advantages and limitations of high consultant verbal cont
rol as a consultation process variable are discussed, and recommendati
ons for future consultation research are offered.