EQUIVALENT EFFICACY OF 1.5-PERCENT PENTOSAN POLYSULFATE SODIUM GEL AND HEPARIN SODIUM GEL IN THE TREATMENT OF SUPERFICIAL THROMBOPHLEBITIS - A CONTROLLED RANDOMIZED DOUBLE-BLIND-STUDY
L. Kollar et al., EQUIVALENT EFFICACY OF 1.5-PERCENT PENTOSAN POLYSULFATE SODIUM GEL AND HEPARIN SODIUM GEL IN THE TREATMENT OF SUPERFICIAL THROMBOPHLEBITIS - A CONTROLLED RANDOMIZED DOUBLE-BLIND-STUDY, Perfusion, 9(3), 1996, pp. 104-108
In a controlled randomized double-blind study including 109 surgical p
atients above 18 years of age of either sex suffering from superficial
infusion thrombophlebitis the efficacy and compatibility of the 3 t.i
.d. application over a mean period of 6.33 days with 1.5% pentosan pol
ysulfate sodium gel (Na-PPS) was studied in comparison to heparin-Na g
el 60.000 (Thrombophob((R))-60.000 Gel). According to a randomized sch
edule 54 patients received Na-PPS, the remaining 55 patients received
heparin-Na. All patients suffered from medium thrombophlebitis persist
ing over apt. 17 hours, which was mostly localized in the cubital area
of the left arm. On days 0 (baseline), 1, 3 and 7 the extent of the t
enderness, reddening, temperature, hardening and swelling were rated u
sing a four-point scale, on which value ''1'' corresponded to the cond
ition ''not present'', ''2'' the condition ''light'', ''3'' the condit
ion ''medium'' and ''4'' the condition ''severe''. In addition, on day
s 0, 3 and 7 leucocytes and blood sedimentation rate (BSR) were determ
ined, and the compatibility was analysed upon completion of the therap
y using a three-point scheme with ''good'', ''medium'' and ''poor''. T
he main efficacy criterion was the total score of all five symptoms of
thrombophlebitis to be rated or the respective alteration on days 3 a
nd 7 of therapy. On both days Na-PPS and heparin-Na proved equivalent
efficacy,vith a significant advantage for Na-PPS on day 3, pointing to
the somewhat higher efficacy of Na-PPS specifically during the first
days. Leucocyte levels and blood sedimentation rate (BSR) underwent co
mparable changes with both therapies. Both treatments were well tolera
ted by the patients; over the total observation time no adverse events
whatsoever were observed in any of the patients. Thus 1.5% pentosan p
olysulfate sodium gel proved its efficacy in the treatment of infusion
thrombophlebitis to be at least equal to heparin-Na gel 60.000. There
fore, 1.5% Na-PPS is an alternative bearing less in the percutaneous t
reatment of infusion thrombophlebitis risk compared to heparin-Na gel
made of animal starting material.