A role of the geometrical effect was investigated based on the precise
structure analyses of the isolated intramolecular hydrogen-bonded sys
tem, h-BrHPLN, d-BrHPLN and MeHPLN. The hydrogen bond lengths (R(OO))
are almost identical for hydrogen and deuterium compounds of BrHPLN, a
nd also in MeHPLN. This means that the geometrical effect is really su
ppressed in the intramolecular hydrogen-bonded system. The reason why
the BrHPLN system shows a large isotope effect on the phase transition
s and MeHPLN does not may be ascribable to the difference in the natur
e of the hydrogen bonds in each compound.