R. Wiles et J. Higgins, DOCTOR-PATIENT RELATIONSHIPS IN THE PRIVATE-SECTOR - PATIENTS PERCEPTIONS, Sociology of health & illness, 18(3), 1996, pp. 341-356
Recent challenges to medical authority have been viewed as having an i
mpact on relationships between doctors and patients. It is argued that
these challenges have resulted in moves away from traditional paterna
listic relationships. As a result of their market position, private pa
tients as a group might be expected to be most advanced in bringing ab
out change in the doctor-patient relationship. Using data collected fr
om a study of private patients, an analysis of patients' interpretatio
ns of their relationships with their doctors was undertaken. The patie
nts' accounts indicated that relationships contained elements of both
mutuality and consumerism. The features of the interaction, the organi
sation of health care in the private sector and the power of the medic
al profession are used to explain how these relationships develop. It
is argued that there are tensions that exist in reality between the pr
inciples underlying each model which constrain relationships between d
octors and patients moving too far in the direction of either consumer
ism or mutuality.