M. Hancock et W. Ickes, EMPATHIC ACCURACY - WHEN DOES THE PERCEIVER-TARGET RELATIONSHIP MAKE A DIFFERENCE, Journal of social and personal relationships, 13(2), 1996, pp. 179-199
This study sought to determine whether a friend-observer who eavesdrop
s on a friend-interactant's initial conversation with a stranger will
be more accurate in inferring the friend-interactant's thoughts and fe
elings than will either the stranger-interaction partner or a stranger
-observer. The empirical answer in this case was 'no', suggesting that
the meaning context established in the interactants' initial conversa
tion was generic rather than esoteric (i.e. it did not uniquely benefi
t the empathic accuracy of the friend-observer). The findings also rev
ealed, however, that nearly half of the variance in the perceivers' em
pathic accuracy scores was accounted for by differences in the overall
'readability' of the various targets; and that, contrary to the cultu
ral stereotype regarding the superiority of 'women's intuition', there
was no reliable sex difference in the perceivers' empathic accuracy s
cores. The discussion focused on the conditions in which the hypothesi
zed empathic advantage of the friend-observer might be evident.