Hj. Smith et R. Spears, ABILITY AND OUTCOME EVALUATIONS AS A FUNCTION OF PERSONAL AND COLLECTIVE (DIS)ADVANTAGE - A GROUP ESCAPE FROM INDIVIDUAL BIAS, Personality & social psychology bulletin, 22(7), 1996, pp. 690-704
Just as reactions to resentment are related to whether people feel dis
advantaged as single actors or as group representatives, viewing onese
lf as an individual actor or a group representative can influence eval
uations of personal ability and outcomes in inequitable situations. An
experimental study investigated the influence of individual versus gr
oup identity salience on evaluations of task ability and the attractiv
eness of rewards based on performance. It was predicted that when indi
vidual identity was made salient, participants' evaluations would refl
ect their likely personal outcomes in such a way as to rationalize the
ir personal (dis)advantage. In contrast, it was predicted that the sal
ience of group identity would release participants from this tendency
to justify these disparities in personal terms. The results support th
is hypothesis and suggest the importance of group identity in protecti
ng against the biased individual rationalization of personal outcomes,
especially under conditions of collective disadvantage.