There has been considerable debate about both the mechanisms controlli
ng primary production, and the interpretation of data from Fe-enrichme
nt experiments conducted in high nitrate-low chlorophyll (HNLC) region
s. This paper presents results of 3 in vitro Fe-enrichment experiments
performed in May 1993 and May 1994 at Ocean Station Papa (OSP) in the
NE subarctic Pacific. Expt 1 (May 1993) considered jointly the influe
nce of both Fe supply and microzooplankton herbivory on algal stocks,
while the second (May 1993) investigated the influence of Fe supply on
the partitioning of C, N and Fe between algal size classes. The third
study (May 1994) monitored changes in phytoplankton stocks in Fe-enri
ched carboys containing mesozooplankton. Assuming similar environmenta
l conditions in May 1993 and 1994, then the combined findings indicate
that under ambient conditions autotrophic cells <5 mu m compose >70 %
of algal biomass, primarily utilized ammonium, showed no Fe-mediated
enhancement of N-normalized nitrate or ammonium uptake, and were thus
unlikely to be Fe-limited. Although the coupling between grazer mortal
ity and algal growth of these cells (g/mu) was ca 0.71 +/- 0.25, they
grew at close to maximal rates but exhibited negligible net growth rat
es, suggesting strong grazer control. Dissolved iron (DFe) supply prom
oted a rapid increase in the abundance of large, initially rare, diato
ms (mainly Nitzschia spp.) over 6 d, elevated diatom growth rates to c
lose to their theoretical maximum and increased rates of incorporation
of N-normalized nitrate and Fe by these cells over time. Unlike the s
mall cells, stocks of large autotrophs also increased in the controls;
DFe measurements indicate that this was probably due to inadvertent F
e contamination. The development of a phytoplankton population, of a c
ell size probably too large to be grazed at a significant rate by micr
ozooplankton, resulted in a decoupling of herbivory and algal growth.
In addition, mesozooplankton herbivory appeared unable to prevent the
accumulation of these large cells; in May 1994, Fe supply prompted an
8-fold increase in algal stocks over 6 d in carboys where grazers equi
valent to the maximum annual in situ pelagic abundance were present. T
he findings agree with the theories of others, that Fe supply rather t
han grazing provides the ultimate control over the phytoplankton commu
nity in the NE subarctic Pacific.