A hypothesis is proposed that unifies prostatic developmental biology
and carcinogenesis. The foundation of this hypothesis is the reciproca
l interaction of epithelium and mesenchyme during prostatic developmen
t followed thereafter by a reciprocal homeostatic interaction of epith
elium and smooth muscle in adulthood. This smooth muscle-epithelial ce
ll interaction is perturbed during prostatic carcinogenesis with adver
se sequelae for both epithelium and smooth muscle. The following seque
nce of events is proposed to occur: (1) Under the influence of androge
ns, urogenital sinus mesenchyme (UGM) induces urogenital sinus epithel
ium to undergo prostatic ductal morphogenesis and differentiation. (2)
As prostatic epithelium differentiates, it in rum signals the UGM to
differentiate into smooth muscle cells that closely surround the epith
elial ducts. Differentiation of prostatic smooth muscle requires both
an inductive signal from epithelium and androgens. (3) Once formed, pr
ostatic smooth muscle participates in reciprocal homeostatic interacti
ons. We propose that prostatic smooth muscle under the influence of an
drogens signals to prostatic epithelium to maintain epithelial differe
ntiation and to repress epithelial proliferation, while prostatic epit
helium signals to prostatic smooth muscle to maintain smooth muscle di
fferentiation. In adulthood, homeostasis is maintained through recipro
cal interactions between smooth muscle and epithelial cells with minim
al proliferation of either cell type. Prostatic carcinogenesis, which
is initiated following genetic damage to prostatic epithelium, is surm
ised to involve a sequential disruption in these reciprocal homeostati
c interactions with ensuing dedifferentiation of both the emerging pro
static carcinoma cells and smooth muscle. Thus, following genetic insu
lt to prostatic epithelium the epithelium fails to signal appropriatel
y to the smooth muscle, which then begins to dedifferentiate. As smoot
h muscle differentiation begins to deviate, signaling from prostatic s
mooth muscle to prostatic epithelium becomes anomalous resulting in pr
ogressive loss of control over epithelial differentiation and prolifer
ation. During progression of prostatic carcinogenesis a vicious cycle
is established in which both prostatic epithelium and smooth muscle de
differentiate. This hypothesis is based on the ontogeny of prostatic s
mooth muscle differentiation during development and by the fact that t
he amount of smooth muscle progressively diminishes in human prostatic
adenocarcinomas during progression from low- to high-grade cancers. F
inally, in experimental tissue recombinants in which various normal or
neoplastic prostatic epithelia were grown in combination with embryon
ic rat UGM, only normal (nonneoplastic) epithelia were capable of indu
cing differentiation of prostatic smooth muscle in UGM. Based on sever
al lines of evidence, it is now apparent that smooth muscle-epithelial
interactions are the operative cell-cell interaction in the postnatal
prostate which plays a key role in regulating epithelial differentiat
ion, proliferation and carcinogenesis.