The toxicity of nickel, chromium (III) and (VI), vanadium and aluminiu
m was compared in an immortalized neonatal rat osteoblast cell line us
ing the MTT assay and a novel index of cytoxicity, alkaline phosphatas
e (ALP) activity. Where toxicity was observed, ALP was a consistently
more sensitive detection method than the MTT assay. The toxicity of th
e metals increased in the order aluminium < chromium (III) < vanadium
< nickel < chromium (VI). alpha-Tocopherol partially prevented nickel-
induced toxicity (as assessed by ALP activity), whereas ascorbic acid
had no protective effect. Chromium (VI) was more toxic than (III), wit
h significant toxicity observed at 0.5 mu M. It is thought that Cr (II
I) cannot readily penetrate the cell membrane and this may account for
the lower toxicity. Aluminium had a stimulatory effect on cell growth
at low concentrations (0.5 mu M). The combination of immortalized rat
osteoblasts and the ALP activity test provides a powerful tool for in
vitro testing of orthopaedic materials. (C) 1996 Elsevier Science Lim
ited