The preparations and structures of three vaulted cyclidene complexes a
re compared with the two previously reported. All show similar structu
res with large rigid cavities partly closed off by the piperidine rise
rs, illustrating in particular the attractive effect of van der Waals
forces resulting in the incorporation of solvent molecules or [PF6](-)
ions nesting on the edges of the cavities. However, the detailed geom
etries vary, according to the nature of the ligand substituents, the m
etal, the counter-ion and the lattice solvent molecules. These give ri
se to differing orientations of the capping aromatic rings and the pip
eridine risers.