G. Mansergh et al., COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF SHORT-COURSE ZIDOVUDINE TO PREVENT PERINATAL HIV TYPE-1 INFECTION IN A SUB-SAHARAN AFRICAN DEVELOPING-COUNTRY SETTING, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 276(2), 1996, pp. 139-145
Objective.-To evaluate the cost-effectiveness of a short-course zidovu
dine program to prevent perinatal transmission of human immunodeficien
cy virus (HIV) type 1 in sub-Saharan African country settings. Design
and Setting.-Several clinical trials of short-course zidovudine during
pregnancy for prevention of perinatal transmission of HIV are under w
ay in developing countries in sub-Saharan Africa. A decision model was
used to examine the cost-effectiveness of zidovudine programs in a hy
pothetical 1-year birth cohort in a sub-Saharan African setting from t
he perspective of the health care system and of society. A completed s
hort course of zidovudine was assumed to reduce perinatal HIV transmis
sion from 25% to 16.5%, approximately one half of the effect of the lo
nger-course zidovudine. Estimates of program costs, lifetime HIV-relat
ed health care costs, and lost productivity costs were derived from th
e published literature and from preliminary data available from sites
of planned clinical trials. Sensitivity analyses were conducted on all
relevant parameters. Main Outcome Measures.-Medical costs, lost produ
ctivity costs, program costs, cost savings, and incremental cost-effec
tiveness, expressed as cost per infant HIV infection prevented. Result
s.-The model estimated that a national zidovudine program in a setting
with 12.5% HIV seroprevalence would reduce perinatal HIV incidence by
12% (4.9 infections per 1000 births), The cost to the health care sys
tem would be $3748 per infant HIV infection prevented. When productivi
ty losses were included in the model, the cost decreases to $1115 per
infant HIV infection prevented. The cost to implement a national zidov
udine program including the cost of counseling, testing, and drugs, wo
uld be $2 million per 100 000 births or $20 per pregnant woman. In the
base case, decreases in the cost of counseling and testing and increa
ses in maternal HIV prevalence, zidovudine efficacy, and medical and l
ost productivity costs improved cost-effectiveness of the zidovudine p
rogram. Conclusions.-Assuming demonstrable efficacy of short-course zi
dovudine prevention of perinatal HIV, a national perinatal HIV prevent
ion program with zidovudine in most sub-Saharan African country settin
gs would reduce the incidence of infant HIV infection and, in some set
tings, provide societal savings; however, substantial initial investme
nt in such programs will be required. Where health care resources are
limited, as in these regions, allocation of resources to a perinatal z
idovudine program will need to be considered in the context of resourc
es required for other pressing medical care needs.