Ej. Chaneton et al., NITROGEN AND PHOSPHORUS CYCLING IN GRAZED AND UNGRAZED PLOTS IN A TEMPERATE SUBHUMID GRASSLAND IN ARGENTINA, Journal of Applied Ecology, 33(2), 1996, pp. 291-302
1. The distribution and dynamics of N and P were studied for two adjac
ent grazed and ungrazed areas of native grassland in the Flooding Pamp
a, Argentina, over the winter-spring season of maximum primary product
ion. We evaluated how grazing effects on vegetation structure altered
patterns of nutrient cycling at the ecosystem level. Nutrient transfer
s were estimated from element concentrations measured in plant and soi
l pools at minimum and peak standing crop and from previous work in th
e study area. 2. Total nutrient amounts in vegetation (9.4-12.6 g m(-2
) N and 0.50-0.76 g m(-2) P) did not differ consistently between graze
d and ungrazed grassland, but nutrient location reflected the effect o
f cattle on phytomass structure and species composition. Plant pools o
f N and P were mainly located in below-ground organs, to the extent of
80-90% in grazed and 63-75% in ungrazed vegetation. Nutrients in abov
e-ground green material from grazed prairie were 50% of the content fo
r ungrazed prairie. At peak standing crop the grazed grassland contain
ed more than 50% N and P in forb biomass, whereas protected vegetation
had most nutrients in graminoids. 3. Nitrogen concentration in live s
hoots declined through the season while it was increasing in roots, in
dicating preferential below-ground allocation. Seasonal patterns of pl
ant N were amplified by continuous grazing. Phosphorus allocation appe
ared to be closely regulated in this grassland. Although changes in sh
oot P concentrations were subtle, P allocation to shoots seemed higher
in ungrazed grassland. Shoot N:P ratios suggested that vegetation was
relatively more P-limited in early winter, but more N-limited in late
spring. 4. In general, N and P contents tended to increase in living
vegetation and to decrease in dead plant compartments over the season
studied. Nutrient uptake by roots was 30-50% higher in the grazed plot
, in correspondence with enhanced mineralization rates. Concentrations
of N and P in graminoid live shoots were also higher under grazing, a
lthough grazing decreased the overall translocation of N to shoots. Li
vestock consumption represented more than 40% of above-ground nutrient
translocation, and thus grazing increased nutrient how through the be
low-ground plant pathway. Strong demand from underground sinks in graz
ed vegetation probably contributed to increased root uptake. Grazing d
id not affect soil-available nutrients, although it did accelerate nut
rient cycling rates, mostly of P. 5. Ammonia volatilization and N expo
rts through cattle removal were of similar magnitude (0.22g m(-2) year
(-1) N), and were 60% of wet deposition. Therefore, N tended to accumu
late in this grassland. Annual P outputs in animal biomass produced a
small net loss of P from the managed ecosystem.