Na. Straw et al., PHYTOTOXICITY OF INSECTICIDES USED TO CONTROL APHIDS ON SITKA SPRUCE,PICEA-SITCHENSIS (BONG) CARR, Crop protection, 15(5), 1996, pp. 451-459
Treatment of 2-4 year old Sitka spruce in the field with the insectici
des dimethoate, malathion, pirimicarb, Pynosect (pyrethrum + resmethri
n) and Savona (insecticidal soap) applied as foliage sprays, and diazi
non, chlorpyrifos and malathion applied as soil drenches, at standard
rates, revealed no adverse effects on tree growth or needle densities.
However, Savona caused needle browning and trees treated with chlorpy
rifos showed a 25% increase in height growth (P < 0.01) and a 13% incr
ease in side shoot extension growth (P < 0.05) after 2 years compared
with control trees. Trials on potted plants with insecticides applied
at the standard rate (X1) or twice the standard rate (X2) revealed no
effects on height growth for any compound by the end of the growing se
ason, but showed that all the insecticides tested had some effect on p
lant dry weight (DW) or needle density. Dimethoate and malathion at th
e X1 rate increased shoot growth, whereas malathion at X2 and Pynosect
at X1 and X2 were noticeably phytotoxic. Root DWs were not increased
or were reduced more than shoot DW, which led to significant reduction
s in root:shoot ratios. The low plant DWs in the Pynosect treatments w
ere associated with a high rate of plant mortality (13-30%), whereas p
lant survival in the other treatments was generally good. Needle densi
ties on the new leader were reduced by the X2 pirimicarb treatment and
by both rates of Pynosect and chlorpyrifos. Needle retention on the p
revious year's leader was reduced by Pynosect acid chlorpyrifos. Indiv
idual needles on the new leader were distinctly smaller on transplants
sprayed with malathion or with Pynosect at the X2 rate, whereas needl
es remaining on the previous year's leader were heavier on trees in th
e X1 malathion treatment. Crown Copyright (C) 1996 Published by Elsevi
er Science Ltd.