POSITIVE ALLERGOLOGICAL TESTS MAY TURN NEGATIVE WITH NO FURTHER EXPOSURE TO THE SPECIFIC ALLERGEN - A LONG-TERM, PROSPECTIVE, FOLLOW-UP-STUDY IN PATIENTS ALLERGIC TO PENICILLIN
G. Patriarca et al., POSITIVE ALLERGOLOGICAL TESTS MAY TURN NEGATIVE WITH NO FURTHER EXPOSURE TO THE SPECIFIC ALLERGEN - A LONG-TERM, PROSPECTIVE, FOLLOW-UP-STUDY IN PATIENTS ALLERGIC TO PENICILLIN, Journal of investigational allergology & clinical immunology, 6(3), 1996, pp. 162-165
Preliminary literature reports suggest the possibility that, in an all
ergic patient, a previously positive allergological test may turn nega
tive after a long period of time with no further exposure to the speci
fic allergen. The aim of this study was to evaluate the rate by which
a previously positive skin test or RAST may turn negative in a group o
f patients allergic to penicillin if no further exposure to the specif
ic allergen occurs. Sixty-three patients allergic to penicillin (48 wi
th type I allergy and 15 with type IV allergy) were enrolled in a long
-term, prospective, follow-up study, undergoing a successive complete
allergological testing within 6 years of the first positive examinatio
n. During the follow-up period, skin tests progressively became negati
ve in 28 (58.3%) type I allergic patients and in only one (6.7%) subje
ct with type IV allergy. Similarly, the positive RAST turned negative
in as many as 13 subjects (43.3% of cases). The cumulative skin test p
ositivity (type I allergy) was significantly lower than that of patch
tests (type IV allergy) (chi(2) = 10.4; d.f. = 1; p < 0.005, Logrank t
est). No significant difference in the progressive rate of decrease in
skin test and RAST cumulative positivity was observed in the 30 patie
nts showing both RAST and skin test positivity on entering the follow-
up study. Our results provide strong evidence that a positive allergol
ogical test performed in a drug-allergic patient may become negative w
ith time, in the absence of further exposure to the specific antigen.
A negative allergological test cannot, therefore, rule out the immunol
ogical basis of a drug sensitivity. This is why we always suggest advi
sing patients with a personal history of drug hypersensitivity against
any further administration of the responsible drug, even in the prese
nce of a completely negative allergological examination.