Jh. Jones, CHONDRITE MODELS FOR THE COMPOSITION OF THE EARTHS MANTLE AND CORE, Philosophical transactions-Royal Society of London. Physical sciences and engineering, 354(1711), 1996, pp. 1481-1494
The terrestrial planets of the inner Solar System are believed to be b
roadly chondritic in composition. Here I suggest that the lithophile e
lement composition of the terrestrial mantle, as approximated by primi
tive lherzolites having high Al/Si ratios and low Mg/Si ratios, was es
tablished by nebular rather than indigenous processes. The implication
s of this model include: (i) the Mg/Si ratio of the upper mantle is an
intrinsic property of the bulk Earth and does not reflect differentia
tion of a terrestrial magma ocean; (ii) the Moon probably did not form
by a giant impact on to the Earth; (iii) refractory lithophile elemen
ts should be 2.5-3.0 chondrites in the bulk silicate Earth; and (iv) s
ilicon is not a major constituent of the Earth's core.