Dw. Black et al., THE EFFECT OF FLUVOXAMINE, COGNITIVE THERAPY, AND PLACEBO ON ABNORMAL-PERSONALITY TRAITS IN 44 PATIENTS WITH PANIC DISORDER, Journal of personality disorders, 10(2), 1996, pp. 185-194
The authors report findings from 44 outpatients with panic disorder wh
o completed an 8 week randomized trial of fluvoxamine (n = 17), cognit
ive therapy (n = 13), or placebo (n = 14). Subjects were given the Per
sonality Diagnostic Questionnaire-Revised (PDQ-R) before and after the
trial. Patients in the three treatment cells were well matched. Nearl
y 32% met criteria for a personality disorder at the baseline assessme
nt, and there were no significant differences among the treatment grou
ps, For the 3 groups combined, the total PDQ-R score had declined sign
ificantly by week 8 (p = .03). Of the 17 PDQ-R traits present in at le
ast 1/3 of the sample, 82% showed a decline in the cognitive therapy c
ell, whereas 53% did not change in the fluvoxamine cell and 41% increa
sed in the placebo cell. ''Personality profiles'' were created and sho
wed that cognitive therapy was associated with the greatest reduction
in abnormal traits, specifically those in the schizotypal, narcissisti
c, borderline, and compulsive categories. Axis II traits were relative
ly resistant to change with placebo or fluvoxamine. The clinical impli
cations of the findings are discussed.