A COMPARISON OF WSR-88D REFLECTIVITIES, SSM I BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURES, AND LIGHTNING FOR MESOSCALE CONVECTIVE SYSTEMS IN TEXAS .1. RADAR REFLECTIVITY AND LIGHTNING/
Er. Toracinta et al., A COMPARISON OF WSR-88D REFLECTIVITIES, SSM I BRIGHTNESS TEMPERATURES, AND LIGHTNING FOR MESOSCALE CONVECTIVE SYSTEMS IN TEXAS .1. RADAR REFLECTIVITY AND LIGHTNING/, Journal of applied meteorology, 35(6), 1996, pp. 902-918
This is the first part of a two part study. Part I compares radar data
from the League City, Texas, WSR-88D and cloud-to-ground (CG) lightni
ng data for a set of eight mesoscale convective systems (MCSs), which
occur al various stages of development along the upper Texas gulf coas
t. Vertical profiles of radar reflectivity (VPRR) as well as plan view
s and vertical cross sections are constructed to characterize the stru
cture and relative strength of each MCS. The VPRR are also compared wi
th similar profiles from tropical oceanic MCSs. The data show that in
all cases the majority of negative CG lightning flashes are located ne
ar high-reflectivity convective cores (>35 dBZ) in the mixed-phase reg
ion (0 degrees C less than or equal to T greater than or equal to -20
degrees C). Growing or mature MCSs typically had larger negative flash
counts and higher percentages of negative lightning (>80%) associated
with convective cores than MCSs al later stages of their life cycle.
Comparison of the median VPRR for the various MCSs showed that althoug
h each case had high-reflectivity cores (45-55 dBZ) in the lowest 2-3
km, the more electrically active MCSs were characterized by smaller re
flectivity lapse rates (decrease of reflectivity with height) in mixed
-phase region than the cores in the remaining systems. Based on existi
ng theories of charge separation, the observation of high negative fla
sh counts coincident with convective cores having small reflectivity l
apse rates in the mixed phase region is consistent with the presence o
f large ice particles aloft. Positive CG flashes were mostly located i
n low reflectivity (less than 30 dBZ near the -10 degrees C level) str
atiform regions, independent of MCS life cycle stage or VPRR type. Sev
eral cases with reports of large hail also had high positive flash den
sities associated with high reflectivity cores. Part II of this study
compares 85-GHz brightness temperatures from the Special Sensor Microw
ave/Imager to lightning data for the same set of MCSs in Part I. Resul
ts from both parts of this study strongly suggest that the presence of
large ice particles aloft is the common linkage between MCSs with lig
htning, with high radar reflectivity aloft, and large 85-GHz temperatu
re depressions.