A. Paganinihill et Vw. Henderson, THE EFFECTS OF HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY, LIPOPROTEIN CHOLESTEROL LEVELS, AND OTHER FACTORS ON A CLOCK DRAWING TASK IN OLDER WOMEN, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 44(7), 1996, pp. 818-822
OBJECTIVES: To assess the associations of a clock drawing task with ho
rmone replacement therapy and other factors in older women. DESIGN: Gr
oup comparisons. SETTING: Leisure World Laguna Hills, a retirement com
munity in southern California. PARTICIPANTS: Two hundred ninety-two po
stmenopausal women tube were analyzed for lipoprotein levels in 1987-8
8 were contacted by postal survey, which included a clock drawing task
, in 1992; 168 women who drew normal clocks were compared with 46 who
drew abnormal or blank clocks. MEASUREMENTS: Clock drawings, lipoprote
in cholesterol levels; serum progesterone, estrone, estradiol, and ste
roid hormone binding globin levels; self-reported data on smoking, alc
ohol intake, prior medical diagnoses, and use of certain medications i
ncluding hormone replacement therapy and analgesics. RESULTS: Women wi
th normal clocks had significantly lower total cholesterol (P=.01), LD
L cholesterol (P=.03), and serum progesterone levels (P=.03). They wei
ghed, on average, 5 more pounds at the time of last menstrual period (
P=.05), were more likely to use combined hormonal replacement therapy
(P=.06), and were less likely to use acetaminophen daily (P=.02) than
women with abnormal clocks. Serum estrone and estradiol levels did not
differ significantly between women with normal and abnormal clocks. C
ONCLUSION: The associations found here suggest that high serum cholest
erol and progesterone levels might have a negative effect on clock dra
wing performance. Acetaminophen may also be related to worse performan
ce on this task.