Gw. Plumb et al., ARE WHOLE EXTRACTS AND PURIFIED GLUCOSINOLATES FROM CRUCIFEROUS VEGETABLES ANTIOXIDANTS, Free radical research, 25(1), 1996, pp. 75-86
Fruits and vegetables contain several classes of compounds that can po
tentially contribute to antioxidant activity, including vitamins, simp
le and complex phenolics, sulphur-containing compounds and glucosinola
tes. The glucosinolates are found in high concentration in many crucif
erous vegetables, and it is well established that their breakdown prod
ucts induce endogenous antioxidant defences such as quinone reductase
and glutathione S-transferase in cells and in vivo. Despite the antica
rcinogenic effect of these compounds in animal models, the direct anti
oxidant properties of this class of compounds have not been systematic
ally studied. We therefore examined the free radical-scavenging proper
ties of representative extracts and of purified glucosinolates from cr
uciferous vegetables, by measuring their effect on ascorbate- or NADPH
/iron-induced peroxidation of human liver microsomes, ascorbate/iron-i
nduced peroxidation on phospholipid liposomes, iron chelation and hydr
oxyl radical scavenging using the deoxyribose assay, total antioxidant
potential using ABTS 2'-azinobis(3-ethyl-benzothiazoline-6-sulphonate
)) and the bleomycin assay. Most of the extracts from cruciferous vege
tables exhibited some antioxidant properties, although extracts from c
ooked Brussels sprouts increased the rate of microsomal lipid peroxida
tion. The effects in these assays were dependent upon processing and s
pecies of crucifer, and the glucosinolate content appeared to play a m
inor role in these effects, since purified glucosinolates exhibited on
ly weak antioxidant properties. The total antioxidant activities of ex
tracts from cooked and autolysed Brussels sprouts were identical withi
n experimental error. This is probably due to the content of phenolics
which is unaltered by autolysis, despite the differences between thes
e samples in other assays especially NADPH-iron-induced lipid peroxida
tion of human liver microsomes. The results demonstrate that glucosino
lates are unlikely to account for the direct antioxidant effects of ex
tracts from cruciferous vegetables.