Rl. Bugg et al., COMPARISON OF 32 COVER CROPS IN AN ORGANIC VINEYARD ON THE NORTH COAST OF CALIFORNIA, Biological agriculture & horticulture, 13(1), 1996, pp. 63-81
In a replicated study conducted from 1990 to 1992, cover crops and a c
ontrol (resident vegetation) were evaluated in an organic wine-grape v
ineyard (cv. 'Chardonnay'), located at a valley floor site in Hopland,
Mendocino County, California. The purpose was to assess plant phenolo
gy, stature, biomass production, competitiveness with resident vegetat
ion, and second-year stand regeneration or persistence in an untilled
vineyard. Legumes (Fabaceae) evaluated included nine annual and two pe
rennial types of clover (Trifolium spp.), bell bean and three other ty
pes of Vicia, two types of cool-season annual medic (Medicago spp.), f
ield pea (Pisum sativum ssp. arvense), a mixture of biennial sweetclov
ers (Melilotus alba and M. officinalis), broadleaf birdsfoot trefoil (
Lotus corniculatus). There were six types of cool-season annual grasse
s (Poaceae) including three cereal grains. Native Californian perennia
l grasses included one rhizomatous and five bunch types. The sole repr
esentative of Brassicaceae was black mustard (Brassica nigra). Unseede
d, resident vegetation plots served as a control. In the first year af
ter seeding, all cover crops except purple needlegrass (Nassella pulch
ra) established stands. Observations of phenological state suggested p
articularly advanced seed maturity by early May for the annual grasses
barley, rattail fescue, soft chess, and cereal rye, as well as for bu
rr medic and 'Dalkeith' subterranean clover. By contrast, 'Austrian Wi
nter' field pea. berseem clover, biennial sweetclovers, and perennial
legumes had not begun flowering. Other entries were at various stages
of flowering. Height was generally greatest for black mustard followed
by annual grasses, perennial grasses, vetches, field pea, and was sim
ilar for annual clovers and medics. Eighteen cover-crop regimes produc
ed vegetational cover in excess of 90%. Particularly great percentages
of vegetational cover were obtained for control (resident vegetation)
, common vetch (Vicia sativa), annual ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum), o
at (Avena sativa), and berseem clover(Trifolium alexandrinum), Particu
larly small percentages of vegetational cover by cover crops occurred
(in increasing order) for creeping red fescue (Festuca, rubra cv. 'Mol
ate'), broadleaf birdsfoot trefoil, and biennial sweetclovers. Particu
larly great biomass estimates were obtained (in decreasing order) for
barley (Hordeum vulgare), oat, black mustard, purple vetch (Vicia begh
alensis), rye, 'Koala' subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum ssp
. brachycalycinum) soft chess (Bromus hordeacens), woollypod vetch (Vi
cia villosa ssp. dasycarpa), and common vetch (Vicia sativa). Especial
ly low biomass production was observed (in increasing order) for creep
ing red fescue (Festuca, rubra), biennial sweetclovers, strawberry clo
ver, meadow barley, and the mix of ladino and strawberry clovers. Biom
ass for resident vegetation in the control plots was significantly gre
ater than biomass produced by creeping red fescue. In the second May f
ollowing seeding, cover crop stands were inspected visually and regene
ration scored qualitatively and subjectively as none, very poor, poor.
fair, good, and very good. Percentage of vegetational cover by crops
was also assessed visually. Stands scored as having good or very good
regeneration were assessed for biomass as in 1991. The following entri
es attained good or very good regeneration: soft chess, California bro
me, annual ryegrass, both forms of blue wildrye, oat, cereal rye, crim
son clover, four varieties of subterranean clover, and both the mixtur
e of ladino and strawberry clovers and the sole seeding of strawberry
clover. Particularly great biomass values were obtained for crimson cl
over and for 'Mt. Barker' and 'Trikkala' subterranean clovers. None of
the three vetches attained high percentages of cover in the second ye
ar; these are thought to benefit from tillage, which was not used in t
his study. Biomass readings were, for the most part, lower than in 199
1. This may have been due to low soil moisture during autumn as a resu
lt of a lack of irrigation and rain.